Plea # 72 to The Onion: Become “Open Source”

April 3rd, 2009

The open source  world has a lot to do with where I am now.  The first company I started was running on a shoe-string budget out of my band’s rehearsal space.  That was 11 years ago, and since then I have grown a fond admiration for open source developers, products, and the collective movement that is wide open to that one great idea someone might have.

That person can build their idea into the conjucation and contribute to the product’s evolution.

I wish The Onion were that way, but sadly, they have an odd closed door policy of no article submissions from writers.

While The Onion is consistently good, I believe it could be consistently great if it were to allow a piece to be submitted from that lone person who just had a great idea at 3 AM.

Even The New Yorker, with their stolid, intellectually elite, cultural epicenter perspective allows contributions.

About once a week something happens to me that could make for a good, perhaps great depending on the writing, Onion article.  I think of The Onion because this type of humor is on my mind.  When my parents go shopping, my father follows my mother around as though she’s his seeing eye dog, becoming increasingly bored and fidgety until he drifts into a dream-state.

That’s when you see him by the make-up counter in Macy’s practicing his golf swing.  The man thinks of golf, and his mind goes there instinctually.

My mind goes to the ironic, crass humor that The Onion has baked into their DNA.

Today an email slipped through our company’s spam filter, spoofed as an authentic Pfizer email regarding Viagra.  The first thing I thought of was, “I wonder how Pfizer’s spam filter deals with the billions of emails about Viagra?”

Is checking the junk folder a regular part of a Pfizer’s employees’ day?  How do they know whether the incoming email from Helen Moore at a hotmail address with Viagra keywords is spam or a woman concerned that her husband has had an erection for 8 hours?

I can imagine an Onion article title:

Pfizer IT Finds 2,987,548 Customer Service Emails in Spam Filter

Conversion or Usability Problem?

April 1st, 2009

Ok, another thing I hear marketers at the conventions I have been attending talk about with great obsession is conversion analysis, and rightly so.

But we do so to the point that we limit our analysis to the conversion zone at the expense of overlooking an equally common cause: usability.

If you reflect on your personal experiences with websites you have abandoned for reasons other than irrelevant content, you’ll probably agree with me that the #1 (or #2) reason you did so had to do with usability.

You couldn’t find something.  The site was too busy and difficult to scan.  The look and feel just kind of annoyed you.

These are the “first touch” reasons that will send most users away from your site before they get to point of considering your value proposition.

And so I have found myself increasingly interjecting, “you don’t have a conversion problem, you have a usability problem”.

The take-away is that scrutiny of landing pages and “conversion” pages should be complemented with studies on usability.

Marketers and the Fallacy of The Bounce Rate

March 31st, 2009

I am in Toronto now for SMX Analytics, largely moderated by Danny Sullivan and Vanessa Fox.

I am so surprised to hear the consistent references to high bounce rate as problems.  This seems irresponsible and short-sighted, as though a user who only accesses one page on your site is a failure of some kind.

Consider Google’s “I’m Feeling Lucky” Button

This search option is there for when you think you know exactly the destination in mind, or just want to add a bit of chance to the search.  Regardless, I would argue that at least 25% of searches are users just looking for one page that has all the information they want.

One Page Visits That Should Not Be More

  • “Definition” searches.  This is a common motive (see my 10 Motives of Search).
  • Contact info - no reason for two pages here.  I’m feeling lucky!
  • Wikipedia searches.  The pages on that site tell a story from A - Z on one massive scrolling page.
  • “First Touch” comparison, research searches.  If you are price comparing, or skimming through options in order to round up a bunch of sites to consider for a purchase, you are less likely to go deep on the first touch.  A bounce here just means you were considered.

The fact is that people want to get where they are going fast, and leave fast, unless you have the unique privilege of running a site like Facebook or ESPN that has a valid reason to engage people.  I am not saying bounce rate has no value as a data source.  I am saying it can be worse than no value, it can give you entirely the wrong picture.  Be careful with bounce.

Measure Impact, Not Bounce

Instead of bounce, consider:

  • Time on site
  • Referring keyword (was it a “one night stand” keyword?  Maybe they found what they were looking for and have no more reason to come back)
  • Return visits - maybe the bounce was a first touch and the user is coming back.

The 10 Motives of Search

February 11th, 2009

Tomorrow I am speaking at SMX West tomorrow. I am going to present my “Motive Analysis”, which is a process I created to identify thematic motive disconnects” between what a visitor is looking for, and how you are messaging to them (this is a very simplistic explanation).

Anyway, in order to comprehend what a Motive Analysis is, it’s important to be familiar with my “10 Motives of Search”.

The “10  Motives” is a list of recurring search motives.

You can download the PDF of the slide I will present tomorrow that has my 10 Motives of Search.

2009: The Time to Assess Analytics?

February 2nd, 2009

We’ve all heard about the many cost-cutting measures companies are taking to survive in what I call “The Post-Bush Economy”.

One measure we haven’t heard enough about is analytics tuning.

We hear about budgets being re-allocated or slashed. Traditional is moving online, viral and buzz are being questioned, RFP’s are going out in hopes of finding less expensive vendors, and so on.

But can an organization truly optimize its channels if it hasn’t made the most of its web analytics data?

As our analytics guru Micah Fisher-Kirshner said in a recent newsletter, “Ironically, most of the large companies we have worked with have such nascent analytics practices that their requirements barely scratch the surface of even GA’s capabilities.”

This leads to the question: how can a company know what to cut, and by how much, unless they have a highly optimized analytics practice?

The first step in budget re-allocationis investing in the enhancement of your analytics practice.

If you are reading this and thinking that your analytics practice is probably not what it should be, contact us, we’ll give you an “analytics check-up” that will ensure your organization can make wise budget decisions to survive in the Post-Bush economy.

Paid Search to Grow 15%

February 2nd, 2009

This will be an interesting year for paid search.

Last year there was about $10B spent in paid - this year could be as much as $12B.

You don’t hear as much talk about viral and buzz campaigns.  Too risky?

How to Increase Business in a Down Market

December 24th, 2008

I began doing SEO in late 1999.  It took me about 18 months to really get the hang of it, as back then there was very little information on SEO.

I was solely responsible for the marketing of my small company (eight people).

The economic collapse hit in 2001, just as the great revenue gains I was generating were kicking in.  And as the economy got worse, my SEO achievements accelerated.  I built many different websites so that each of the four salesmen could operate their own brand.  By doing so, the company would have not just a number one rank for our keywords, but often four.

Our revenue grew and grew, seemingly immune from the economic downturn.  As the overall market decreased for our industry, our market share increased faster.

An article in today’s NY Times describes a merchant who is doing the same, but with paid search.

The merchant has increased  his revenue by doubling his conversion rate, his bid, and his marketing budget.

Think of all the companies out there spending significant amounts on brand campaigns, yet are budget constrained in paid search.

The right move for these marketers is to drastically cut, or eliminate, their under performing non-search campaigns and maximizing their investments in search.

The Chinese Market: Large But Even More Frugal

December 21st, 2008

American marketing agencies are soon going to find out that no matter how good their campaigns are, how many tests they do, or how much money they spend, a surprisingly high number of their performance driven campaigns in China are going to fail.

Why?

There is a lot of talk about China’s economic growth.  American companies are excited to have a Chinese presence.  But the truth is so many companies want to be there but don’t really know why.  There is a sense that something is about to erupt, and not being there equates to missing out.

But is China really that promising?  Sure, China has had double digit growth for years.  But it wasn’t the Chinese who were consuming.  So, before American companies rush over there to sell the Chinese products and services that were selling well elsewhere, let’s stop for a moment to recognize that the Chinese are not a consumer culture.

Stephen Roach, the chairman of Morgan Stanley Asia, called Americans, “the most over-extended consumer in world history.” And now that Americans are no longer buying so many Chinese exports, China will have to find another consumer base for its enormous production machine. And they know it won’t come from within.

As Thomas Friedman wrote:
“China has no real Social Security, health insurance or unemployment insurance. Without that social safety net, it’s hard to see how Chinese don’t end up saving most of their stimulus.”

In the SEM agency world, having a presence in China is important to prospective clients.  This presence represents the gateway to a huge, seemingly untapped market.

The problem, however, is that these agencys’ clients are going to realize that the Chinese will require, according to Fred Hu, chairman for Greater China for Goldman Sachs, a huge “cultural and structural” shift before they start consuming the largely unnecessary products that Americans love.

China will prove to be the largest market, but so frugal that some marketers will realize that it isn’t worth trying.  For example, Adobe Systems essentially ignores the market, recognize that pirating is out of control there, the Chinese government is not helping police the piracy, and that the Chinese consumer doesn’t have the money or mindset to pay for the software.

A wave of companies are about to discover what Adobe knew ten years ago.  China is more stingy than it is large.

Using WordPress as a SEO CMS: Enterprise and Microsite Considerations

December 18th, 2008

I just managed a project to use WordPress as a CMS for an SEO campaign.

WP is getting a lot of attention for its ability to be a flexible CMS.  With nearly a half million plug-ins, it has the largest open source development community of any CMS.  Ironically, it was not meant to be a CMS.

But the development work done by the WP community has given WP the ability to function as a CMS.  When I spoke at OMMA in NYC last year, a fellow panelist was asked for a recommendation on an affordable SEO-friendly CMS.  He answered “WordPress” and I was thinking, “amen!”.

Out of the box, WP is very SEO friendly.  When we piloted our first enterprise launch of WP as a CMS, we encountered many obstacles, such as writing custom title tags and URL handling.  But every problem had a plug-in that was not only free, but very easy to install.

Our front end developer spent about 4 days converting PSD files into WordPress friendly CSS templates.  Once the templates were made, publishing pages was very easy because ANYONE CAN DO IT.

The success of WP has a lot to do with ease of use.  So you can give each business unit or manager their own section and just let them build out their pages when the templates are up.  (Afterwards, have a designer sweep through to make it look professional).

I’ve worked with a number of enterprises, from Adobe, Hearst, Sony, Warner Brothers, and American Express, and a number of small and mid-size companies.

WordPress can, but is very unlikely, to serve the needs to larger companies that need complex publishing rights and version control.  One can, however, recreate this functionality from plug-ins and your own custom scripts. (Note: creating plug-ins for WP is very easy, the code is clean with descriptive inline comments).

But let’s face it, WP is not meant to be an enterprise CMS.  Ford has used WordPress for a microsite, but we have yet to see WP used for websites that have a lot of stakeholders.

As marketers within large companies recognize the inertia they face creating an online presence for business-unit campaigns utilizing centralized resources, they look for inexpensive and easy publishing solutions.  Wordpress is filling that need, and I am excited to contribute as an SEO to continue evolving Wordpress.

Online Etiquette

November 12th, 2008

Here’s a great piece of advice.

Treat people online the same way you would in person.

Think about it.